Armchair Critics' Archives

 

October 2004

The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Nighttime by Mark Haddon

Synopsis

Christopher, a teenage autistic boy, narrates this detective story about his quest to discover who murdered the neighbour's dog. During his investigation, he uncovers a nasty secret about his father and sets out on a difficult journey to learn the truth about his family.

Mark Haddon has written an insightful and often funny book which sheds light on the unique view of the world held by autistic people. The way Christopher will not eat yellow or brown food and refuses to look at people's facial features is disconcerting, but when told in the first person becomes part of a logical belief system. The reader can sense that Christopher's father is barely coping, but the boy's deceptively simple narrative holds all emotion at bay. The illustrations and mathematical formula included in the boy's dialogue add to the sense of great intelligence and alienation.

What the Armchair Critics Thought

While the storyline is fairly simple, this novel was very carefully written. We noted the little idiosyncrasies displayed by Christopher such as describing the number of tiny holes in someone's loafers, or transcribing a letter word for word including the spelling errors. We sympathised with Christopher's father, never being able to hug his son. We theorized whether Christopher would be happier in an institution, with unvarying routines and plenty of mathematic homework to keep him occupied. Would someone stare him in the face one day and scare him into using his penknife? A fascinating read.

September 2004

The Other Boleyn Girl by Philippa Gregory

Synopsis:

This historical novel tells the story of Anne Boleyn's sister Mary, who was the mistress of King Henry VIII for several years before Anne. Brought to the royal court at a young age, the two sisters and their brother George are manipulated behind the scenes by their ambitious uncle. The natural rivalry between the two sisters is heightened by their perilous position as favourites to the king.

Anne is portrayed as the soft-hearted sibling, who longs for a normal home and family life and enjoys spending time with her daughter and son. Anne is the ruthless sister, who will stop at nothing to win the king's heart, even forceably adopting her sister's two children.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

Full of pomp and pageantry, this book is a great read for history buffs and romantics. Although the story's ending is a foregone conclusion, Gregory holds your interest with her detailed dialogue and imaginary motives. The Critics also enjoyed the recent TV movie based on the novel.

June 2004

Fight Club by Chuck Palahniuk

Synopsis:

A seriously disturbed young man, disillusioned with his Ikea furniture and morally bankrupt job meets a strange and charismatic new friend, Tyler Durden. Together they form a new club where groups of like-minded men can come together to relieve their frustrations by beating each other up. The success of this club leads to new fight clubs opening up in major cities everywhere.

When the therapeutic properties of pummeling one another begin to wane, the fight clubs morph into a cult of anarchists lead by Tyler. As the fight clubs begin an active campaign of vandalism and terror, the book spirals downwards into a pit of violence and desperation.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

The member who picked this book enjoyed the edgy, terse writing style, which echoed the tension of the main characters. The protagonists were also appreciated for their passionate tirades against our society's material lifestyle, though we did not agree with their means of dealing with their dissatisfaction. The main plot twist was also nicely done. That being said, this book was almost universally loathed by our group for its violence and mean spirited tone. Tyler -why didn't you channel all that energy into something positive?

May 2004

Oryx & Crake by Margaret Atwood

Synopsis:

A future all too near, all too real and all too frightening. Margaret Atwood sets her tale of post global warming - post globalization in middle America. Citizens of this future state live in gated compounds, where they are protected by their corporate employers from pollution, poverty and criminal activity. The less fortunate reside in the surrounding Pleeblands where they must fend for themselves.

Once upon a time Jimmy was a nice kid, raised in the Organ Inc. compound where his parents worked on organ transplant sources from biologically altered "pigoons". He and his brilliant friend Crake surfed the internet and played computer chess in their luxurious suburban bedrooms. Now Jimmy ekes out an existence on a lonely beach, foraging for weapons and scraps of food in the ruins. A strange race of altered people 'the Crakers' live nearby, eating leaves and grass and peacefully raising their children. The human race is dead. What has become of them?


What the Armchair Critics Thought:

We found this book brilliant, insightful and thought-provoking. All the historical events, inventions, products and social trends could be extrapolated back to the present day. The HealthWizer Compound was disconcertingly similar to a Mexican tourist resort. The computer games and web sites were a logical progression of today's reality TV shows.

The characters and their motivations were fascinating. When did Crake conceive his plan and start using Jimmy as his patsy? Were Crake's actions in the airlock deliberately planned to put Jimmy in shock until it was too late for the world? We also loved the flashes of humour in the product names and corporations. We found everything familiar, and yet slightly altered. Summer vacation on Hudson's Bay, real time executions. Is this our future? How can we prevent it from occuring?

April 2004

The Red Tent by Anna Dimante

Synopsis:


The Biblical tale of Jacob is re-told by Anna Dimante through the eyes of Dinah, his only daughter. The author portrays the lives of women at the time of the Book of Genesis in a clear and compelling fashion. The women gather in the Red Tent during their monthly menstrual cycles to tell stories, sing and nurture one another. As the only daughter among eleven sons, Dinah becomes the keeper of the stories and lore of each of Jacob's four wives, whom she refers to as her four mothers.

Dinah's girlhood abruptly ends when she falls in love with the prince of Hamor. Her brothers accuse her lover of defiling their sister and murder him, along with every male inhabitant of his City. The remainder of the book deals with Dinah's escape to Egypt where she raises her son, becomes a midwife and eventually finds happiness.

What the Armchair Critics Thought

We enjoyed the retelling of this ancient story and the way Dimante crafted the individual personalities of the four wives to explain the Biblical events. Her portrayal of the social customs was fascinating. We spent a fair bit of time speculating about the possibility of having our own red tent where we could get away from the daily routine once a month. We found the latter part of the story, dealing with Dinah's life in Egypt, was told in a completely different style from the beginning section so that you almost felt you had switched to another book. However, we recommend this novel as an interesting slice of historical fiction.

March 2004


Bel Canto by Ann Patchett

Synopsis:

Bel Canto, or "Beautifully Sung" is a wonderfully orchestrated book about a group of hostages and their captors holed up in a presidential mansion for several months. While the first chapters of the book are tense and stressful, as time passes both the prisoners and the terrorists adjust to the restricted world created by their situation. Clothes are washed and meals prepared while written demands are exchanged and the Red Cross representative makes his daily visit.

The lives of major characters including an American opera singer, Japanese business man and his translator, a beautiful female terrorist and the French ambassador are changed forever by the bonds they forge during the ordeal.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

A well crafted book in which the reader is also lulled into a sense of complacency along with the hostages -despite Patchett's warning in the opening chapter. The weight of time was especially well portrayed as the heads of international corporations and the active, highly trained terrorists are all struggle with the unaccustomed lack of activity and discover their hidden gifts. This is a book to be savored, as the plot details the small adjustments and changes that occur during the captivity.

We enjoyed the detailed descriptions, for instance the way the guests sink to the carpet in a rustle of satin and taffeta -the way some women straighten their gowns beneath them, while others -those who expected to be shot, lie down uncaring. The barriers of language and the universal appeal of music were also nicely captured. The book seems to be based on a hostage taking in Peru in the late 1990s.

February 2004


The DaVinci Code by Dan Brown

and/or

Daughter of God by Lewis Perdue

 

Synopsis:

Two books were selected this month because the author of Daughter of God is claiming that some of the research and plot points in the best-selling DaVinci Code were plagiarized from his novel. Both books involve a religious secret hidden by the Catholic Church for centuries. Perdue's novel is a traditional thriller, with gun fights, explosions and an Indiana Jones type trek though an abandoned salt mine. Brown's book is also a page turner, which features a series of puzzles and hidden codes - deciphered by the protagonists at convenient intervals through the novel.

 

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

While the overall themes were of a similar nature, we thought the plot and characters were probably different enough to make a plagiarism charge difficult to prove. (The previous case of plagiarism we discussed: L.M. Montgomery's The Blue Castle and Colleen McCullough's The Ladies of Missaloughi was very clear cut.) It will be very interesting to follow the media coverage of this issue in coming years.

There was a mix of opinion about the two books - some preferred one and some the other. Both had fast-moving, intriguing plotlines and were hard to put down. We all enjoyed the puzzles in Brown's book although felt that his conspiracy theories require a healthy dose of skepticism. Brown's protagonists were compared to Energizer Bunnies as they never seemed to eat or sleep. We also felt that the violent scenes in Perdue's book were described in more detailed than strictly necessary.

Interview with Lewis Perdue

We were excited to have Lewis Perdue contact our web site and offer to phone in during our February meeting. The following is a summary of our very pleasant chat with the author:

Can you tell us anything about the plagiarism issue?
A forensic linguist in the UK has been analysing the "DaVinci Code" along with my previously published books "Daughter of God" and the "DaVinci Legacy". Some interesting correlations have been identified, including a research error in one of the original books which also appears in Brown's book. I have 3 years from the point of infringement to decide whether to bring charges. I have decided to put the issue off for a year and concentrate on my writing. However the forensic report will be made public in the next year.

What message did you want people to take away from "Daughter of God"?
I wanted to draw the comparison between faith and the bureaucracy and power plays that can arise from formalized religion. Secondly I wanted to show how organized religion can work to disenfranchise those who are different from the people who make the rules. For example, the Book of Proverbs is clearly written the voice of a woman and is one of the few parts of the Bible from which this female voice has not been removed. Finally I wanted to illustrate that people can still have faith in a greater power even if they recognize that there are some problems with their religion. Just because the rope that keeps you from falling off the cliff is frayed, you don't let go of it.

Are you currently working on another book with a religious theme?
My latest working title is "Perfect Killers" and is centred around the armed forces and the theme of where human consciousness lies.

Why does Daughter of God have such a high body count?
Actually the number of killings in my books has been decreasing over time. When I first began writing, dead bodies were very much part of the action genre. However, I do think you need a certain amount of violence in any thriller in order to establish that there are some consequences for the hero or heroine -to raise the stakes for them.

Why didn't you do more with Zoe's ability to hear colours as music? This was a really intriguing part of the novel and we were wondering if it was a real phenomenon?
In retrospect, I wish that I had expanded upon her ability. Synaesthesia is an actual condition and it is hypothesized that this may be the way babies perceive the world before their brains are hardwired.

Do you have any trouble writing female characters?
Not at all because I grew up in a household with my mother and sister and I also have several female friends who will tell me if something isn't realistic. For example, one of my heroines was a very tall athletic woman and my friends explained that she would have trouble finding clothes to fit. My books always include strong female characters.

We really enjoyed the way Zoe was able to escape from her cell.
Thank you. I had to do a lot of walking to figure that out. I didn't want any damsel in distress rescue -she had to get herself out of there.

What is your working routine?
I get up at 5am and do 3 hours of writing and editing in a small shed behind my house. No phones and no distractions. This ensures I am not disturbed by left brain thinking because once that happens, my right brain doesn't create as well. I also have an office in my house where I do research, make calls and storyboard my ideas. I go for long walks in the surrounding parks and fields where I just let my subconscious work things out. I usually don't know how my books will end because writing a novel is like running a marathon -if you think about how hard it's going to be to finish, then you'll never start. I generally write about 5 pages per day at the beginning of a book, but this starts to speed up when the end comes into view.

January 2004

The Last Crossing by Guy Vanderhaeghe

Synopsis:

When two brothers travel from Victorian England to seek their lost missionary brother, they gather a cast of other characters on their travels. These characters include: Custis a Civil War veteran, Jerry Potts their half-breed guide, and Lucy a determined young woman who is looking for her sister's killers. As the group journeys by wagon from northern Montana to parts of Saskatchewan and Alberta, the book touches on many facets of Canadian history including smallpox epidemics, the whiskey trade, buffalo hunting, forts, and red river carts.

 

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

Most of the Critics thought the story was engrossing and enjoyed the descriptive passages and attention to historical detail. The characters of Lucy and Custis were found particularly appealing, even though they were rough around the edges! The author handled the alternating points of view very well.

However some members had trouble with the extensive violent imagery ie: the fist fight between Custis and Addington. We were interested to discover that Jerry Potts was a real person and that Fort Whoop Up is now a heritage site near Lethbridge Alberta. It was interesting to learn some more about the Canadian West and how it was perceived by the English gentleman traveler.

 

November 2003

Dolce Agonia by Nancy Huston

Synopsis:

God is the narrator in this gloomy and disturbing novel about a Thanksgiving dinner party held by a middle-aged writer for a group of his friends and associates. Through the eyes of God, we hear the honest and sometimes shocking inner thoughts of each guest, as we also witness their outward conversations and routine actions.

The plot is limited, as most of the story revolves around the memory, flashbacks and innuendo triggered by the polite conversation in the room. As an added bonus feature, God throws in a description of the eventual death of each character at the end of every chapter.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

Although there were no really likable people in the book, it was quite disconcerting to read a novel in which every single character dies. As you learned the ultimate future of each guest, most their actions and thoughts at the dinner party seemed to become trivial. We found ourselves thinking about making the most of every moment -perhaps the main message Huston intended to convey.

October 2003

Too Close to the Falls by Catherine Gildiner

Synopsis:

Catherine Gildiner has written a delightful memoir about her unconventional childhood in Lewiston New York. The book is brimming with wonderful, eccentric characters and funny moments. Four-year-old Catherine suffers from a surplus of energy (which today would be called attention deficit disorder), and is under doctors orders to burn it off.

She is put to work at the family drug store delivering prescriptions with the warmhearted Roy. They are a great partnership; Catherine reads the labels while Roy drives the delivery van and teaches her that you can get all your work done, and still have a little fun.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

We all loved this book, especially the portrayal of Catherine's strong mother, who never made a home-cooked meal in the conventional 1950s - yet held frequent adult conversations with her daughter and taught her a great deal about self reliance. We discussed memory, and how it fades and changes over time and we marveled at the detail which authors like Gildiner can call up in their memoirs. We also enjoyed the local setting of the book, especially the weather references! We'll never read Gildiner's advice column in Chatelaine Magazine without picturing the plucky little girl with the cowgirl hat.

 

September 2003

The Nanny Diaries by Emma McLaughlin & Nicola Kraus

Synopsis:

The two authors of this breezy novel based the plot on their ten years of experience working as nannies in New York. Their fictional Nanny cares for a four year old boy, Grayer, in Manhattan. Grayer's life consists of an endless round of trendy educational experiences, macrobiotic foods, and bewildering play dates from which his parents are conspicuously absent. These upper crust parents are at pains to make Nanny aware of her short falls. Nanny attempts to care for Grayer, appease his parents, complete her degree and hook up with a handsome hottie who lives in the same building.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

We found it interesting to read a book by two authors and wondered how they arranged the responsibilities. The book was well written, with a good balance between Nanny's work and personal life. The name Grayer was appropriate because this was a child who tended to fade out of his parents' social climbing world. Mrs. X, the mother, was a caricature - could anyone be so brittle, demanding and self-absorbed? Her 'spatula move' where she scooped Grayer aside every time he ran to her, was the perfect metaphor for her relationship with him. We noted that the parents could only cope with their complete lack of interest in their son by minimizing and undervaluing the importance of the nanny's job (hence the earmuffs for Christmas).

For interest, a Globe and Mail article on families who bring along a nanny on vacation was circulated. It paralleled the novel to a surprising degree. We also discussed the phenomenon of web cameras in daycares and whether this also showed insecurity in parenting.

June 2003

The Green Mile- by Steven King

Synopsis:

Originally a serialized novel in six parts, the Green Mile tells the story of a death row prison guard who is assigned to watch over John Coffey, an enormous silent man convicted of murdering two young girls. The "green mile" is the guards' name for the inmates' last walk along the green linoleum between the cells on the way to "Old Sparky".

As the story unfolds, Coffey is shown to have strange healing powers, leading Paul Edgecomb and his coworkers to believe that putting the man to death would be a terrible mistake.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

We enjoyed the novel and found it a departure from King's usual horror stories. There was some discussion of the similarities between Coffey and the Christ story. He is certainly a moving figure. Although we were fond of Mr. Jingles, we found his later appearance a little hard to swallow. The parallels between the prison and the nursing home Edgecomb finds himself in are well drawn. We wondered if King made a lot more money by releasing the book in six parts!.

May 2003

Eddie's Bastard- by William Kowalski

Synopsis:

Billy Mann is raised by his alcoholic grandfather after being left in a picnic basket on the threshold of the family farmhouse. Despite this ignoble beginning, Billy grows up on a rich diet of family history and fried bologna and becomes a sweet and sensible young man. Kowalski's first novel is both funny and touching as it demonstrates the power of unstinting love and loyalty. As Billy sets out on the concluding journey, the reader wishes him bonne chance.

 

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

We enjoyed the humour and plot detours throughout this book. The stories of the grandfather's shipwreck, the family curse and the ice storm were wonderfully told. While Billy seemed a little too good to be true, we liked him anyway. As Canadian's we especially appreciated the scene in Quebec when Billy joins the "separatist" parade. We look forward to reading more of Kowalski's work.

April 2003

The Hours- by Michael Cunningham

Synopsis:

This novel describes one day in the lives of three women and interweaves their actions with the plot and dialogue of Virginia Wolfe's book "Mrs. Dalloway". Wolfe is herself a character in the novel, struggling against an eating disorder and her encroaching mental illness while she begins to write a new book. Laura Brown is a young bride struggling against post WWII conventions and suburban lifestyle to find her own individuality. Clarissa Vaughan is a successful professional woman struggling to come to terms with the terminal illness of her best friend. As the hours of the day draw to a close, the outlook and lives of these three women have all been permanently altered.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

We were moved and impressed by the way these women were realistically portrayed and their lives reflected similar themes. The dialogue and scenes paralleled the action in Mrs. Dalloway in a striking and very clever fashion. Many of us had also watched the film and enjoyed the way scenes were mirrored in each of the women's eras (such as the three women putting up their hair). We enjoyed the way that ordinary female activities such as cooking, entertaining and shopping were given their due. The book is a wonderful tribute to Wolfe's novel.

March 2003

The Life of Pi- by Yann Martel

Synopsis:

This fascinating book celebrates the human will to survive. During his journey from India to Canada, young Pi Patel is shipwrecked and winds up sharing a lifeboat with a hyena, an orangutan, a zebra and a Bengal tiger. Pi's incredible story chronicles his struggles against the natural elements as well as against the natural instincts of the tiger. His daily life is outlined in vivid detail as the lack of food, water and shelter and the constant tension take their toll. Eventually surreal elements such as a floating island full of meercats start to surface in the story and prepare the reader for its surprising conclusion.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

This book left us feeling somewhat unbalanced. Which Life of Pi was the real one? It was great fun to look at the parallels between the two stories. We enjoyed the exploration of spirituality as Pi tries to become a Christian, Hindu and Moslem at the same time. His disbelief that there could be only one story in the Christian religion was quite amusing. The descriptive passages were superb, especially those of the night sky above the raft. We are still wondering about the floating island and the teeth in the fruit.

February 2003

American Gods- by Neil Gaiman

Synopsis:

What happens when the gods from all the religions of the world are left abandoned and unworshiped in a strange new land? Some scratch out a living in low wage jobs -taxi drivers, stock boys and fortune tellers. Others move to the margins of society as grifters, petty thieves and prostitutes. They watch as the new gods; television, media and the automobile, rise to power and glory.

Shadow Moon, recently widowed and fresh out of prison, is hired as assistant to the mysterious Mr. Wednesday. During the next few months, in a journey that is part road-trip and part head-trip, Shadow finds himself at centre stage during the war of the gods.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

Neil Gaiman is a master storyteller. This book has a wonderfully intricate storyline, in which small details and casual remarks can be revisited and traced to future events or religious myths. Despite its length, the book was a quick and fascinating read. Shadow is a compelling character: strong, silent and with hidden depths. Gaiman's exploration of middle America and his explanation for the success of tacky roadside attractions was quite fun.

Despite these positive points, reaction to this novel among the Critics was mixed. Some found the violence and horror put them off, despite their interest in the general plot.

January 2003

Miss You Like Crazy- by Eliza Clark

Synopsis:

When Maylou's mama suddenly dies in her Florida trailer park, Maylou sets out to bring her mama's ashes and her father back home to Kansas. The unhappy pair are forced to bring along their neighbour's daughter CeCe when she decides to flee her unfortunate marriage.

On the trip they meet many colourful characters including Sherman the psychic, who falls in love with CeCe and tells her that her husband has been killed by a falling vending machine. At this point, Maylou's father decides to remain with CeCe and Sherman and create a sacred grove of trees by carving sentences into them with a fork. Maylou returns alone to Kansas, and tries to accept the loss of her mother's life while making a fresh start with her own.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

This is a strange little book. Eliza Clark seems to have populated her first novel with every odd character and weird encounter she ever heard of. As a result, the events unfold like a road trip on acid, where neither the people, the situations or the dialogue ring true. Characters are introduced and then dismissed a few pages later, and while we want them to give Maylou some nugget of sound advice for coping with her mother's death -they never do. Despite these failures, there is a sense of sweet sadness in this book that keeps you plugging away until the end in hope that Maylou will be OK.

October 2002

The Good Husband- by Gail Godwin

Synopsis:

Magna Danvers is studying for her final examination. Once a robust, fiery college professor she now lies in her bedroom dying of cancer. But Magda sees her death as a unique opportunity to assess her life. She has nothing to lose or gain and therefore she can judge the motives of those around her with absolute clarity. Her husband Francis, who has devoted 25 years to her career and happiness, knows their marriage is ending, but can not even conceive of his life without her.

Across town, another marriage is ending. Alice Henry, who has seen too many deaths in her lifetime, has recently experienced the stillbirth of her son. Hugo Henry realizes that he does not have the ability to comfort his wife and that their mutual misery will eventually drive them apart. As Alice becomes increasingly involved with the Danvers household and Hugo struggles to begin his next novel, we are able to contrast the two couples and their experiences.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

The person who selected this book did so because she was struck by Gail Godwin's absolutely accurate portrayal of the death of a loved one. She felt that this novel would help its readers grasp the importance of listening to the dying person and of trying to imagine what they are going through -rather than thinking of your own potential loss and brushing aside what they are trying to tell you.

The Critics were impressed by the complexity and detail that went into this book. You felt as if you had read Hugo's novel and had attended one of Magda's lectures. The bits of essays, the speeches and the outlines of stories that were included made you feel that these were real people with real lives. Recommended.

 

September 2002

Watermelon- by Marian Keyes

Synopsis:

Poor Claire! Her husband leaves her for another woman on the day she gives birth to their first child and she travels home to Dublin to recover from the shock in the bosom of her family. She spends the next few weeks alternately crying, drinking & exercising in one of her mother's old nightgown, while her family looks after baby Kate and tries to sympathise with the unwashed maniac Claire has become. The Walsh family (consisting of Claire's four sisters as well as her Mum and Dad) are eccentric and oddly endearing. When Claire eventually digs herself out of her depression and starts to question her marriage, it is her family that provides the financial and moral support to enable her to confront her husband.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

We thought this was a great summer read. Despite the serious topic and events taking place, the book is told in a very funny way. Since it is written in first person, the reader rides along on the hilarious tangents of Claire's thoughts. The book also contains a core of truth in that the attempts of James to put the blame on Claire for the breakdown of their marriage follows a typical pattern. This is Marion Keyes' first novel and we were pleased to learn that she has written two more books about the members of the Walsh family: "Rachel's Holiday" and "Angels".

 

June 2002

A Beautiful Mind- by Sylvia Nasar

Synopsis:

This book is the biography of mathematician John Nash, the Nobel Laureate and father of Economic Game Theory. The book traces Nash's childhood, his college career, his early love affair and bastard child, his eventual marriage, mental breakdown, treatment and recovery.

Along the way, the author discusses Nash's homosexual tendencies, his extreme arrogance and childish manner, his lack of social skills, and fear of failure. Nash's flawed character makes the courageous support of his partner- Alicia Nash, and his university colleagues all the more touching.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

At nearly 400 pages, this book was a tough slog for most of the Critics. Much of the first third of the biography deals with Game Theory and mathematics and is not an easy read. Many of us opted for watching the Oscar winning film instead. We were extremely surprised at how little the film resembled Nash's life. Important elements such as his other son, his divorce and his trips to Europe were completely missing. We also discussed the price of genius and the horror of schizophrenia.

 

May 2002

Wobegon Boy- by Garrison Keillor

Synopsis:

Keillor is an author and humorist known for his weekly radio program "A Prairie Home Companion", which features folksy tales of life in the fictional town of Lake Wobegon. Keillor is the author of several books, including Lake Wobegon Days (1995), Leaving Home (1992) and Happy to Be Here (1990).

In Keillor's latest novel; John Tollefson, a Lake Wobegon native, has moved to New York State to manage a radio station at a college for the "academically challenged children of financially gifted parents". After he buys a house and finds a girlfriend, John sets about trying to find himself

 

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

This is a book badly in need of an interesting plot. Although there were many clever sentences and nicely satirical passages, it was a struggle to complete. Dull, dull, dull.

Partly due to his shoddy treatment of the women in his life, we found the main character was completely unsympathetic and were unsure of why his girlfriend eventually agreed to marry him. Mr. Keillor's characters should stick to Lake Wobegon in future.

 

April 2002

Drowning in Stuff - Produced by Jill Eisen

Synopsis:

This month we listened to a four-part presentation produced for the CBC radio program "Ideas". Each segment was an hour long: Drowning In Stuff, Marketing Cool, Targeting Children, and More Is Not Always Better. The program dealt with consumer culture and the fact that the media normalizes affluence -even though only twenty percent of the population can afford to live at the standard portrayed in most television programs. We are no longer keeping up with the Joneses in our own income bracket - now we are trying to keep up with Frasier Crane. North Americans can purchase hundreds of styles of shoes, household gadgets, toys and other products, but our planet cannot sustain the level of consumption that corporations tell us we are entitled to.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

We were stunned by the information compiled on these tapes. Even though these issues were not new to us, they had more impact because the correlation between over-consumption, our stressful lifestyle, fair labour, environment and economy was so neatly synthesized. Finding out that you are being manipulated is not a pleasant feeling but we can all put our consciences to good use by curbing our impulse purchases and working for justice in the world economy.

March 2002

Any Known Blood by Lawrence Hill

Synopsis:

Raised in the WASP suburbs of Oakville, Ontario by a white mother and a black father, Langston Cane V feels no sense of belonging. In trying to make sense of his own life, Langston sets out to uncover five generations of family history that toggle between Baltimore, Maryland and the shores of Lake Ontario.

 

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

We enjoyed this novel on several levels: as an engaging story, as a look at life on both sides of the US/Canadian border, and as a source of information about the early history of Oakville -where some of us live. We liked the book's use of humour and its many wonderful characters such as Yo Yo and Millie. The book left us wanting to learn more about the Underground Railway and black history in Canada.

We were delighted to have Lawrence Hill as our guest when we discussed this novel. Mr. Hill put everyone at ease with his friendly manner. He spoke about the planning and research for this novel and about his current project. He also gave a short reading from the book.

Some of the questions we asked Mr. Hill were:
What is your writing technique? (Hill plans the major structure of a book and then writes drafts of the various scenes in a free form manner- putting down characters and conversations as they bubble up in his imagination)
Do you feel uncomfortable talking about the steamier scenes of your novels? (no, but when giving a public reading it's best not to read such scenes in full daylight!)
Why does a Canadian writer use US spelling? (it's a more common spelling which facilitates sales in both markets);
Why did you put the kidnapping scene into the novel -it seemed somewhat out of step with the rest of the book? (I wanted to get the two characters in a room together to resolve their past, so I decided to do it in an outrageous fashion and also liked the idea of upsetting people's assumptions about the kidnappers.)
How did your family react to your latest book -the autobiographcial "Black Berry, Sweet Juice: on Being Black and White in Canada? (they were made very uncomfortable by some of the scenes -just as I would be if my children chose to write about their childhood in twenty years time)

 

February 2002

Still Me by Christopher Reeve

Synopsis:

Reeve's autobiography looks back at his incredibly active past and forward to his uncertain future. Before the 1995 riding accident that left him paralysed below the neck, Reeve enjoyed life in the fast lane -flying planes, horseback riding, and filming in exotic locations. Today his daily routine depends upon a small army of staff who dress, feed and bathe him. Reeve has become a leading activist for spinal cord research and his Christopher Reeve Foundation has raised over a million dollars toward the quest for a cure.

Reeve tells his story in an honest, straightforward manner. The book was dictated to ghost writer June Fox during daily recording sessions at his home in New York. Chapters are organized around key themes: the accident, his time in rehabilitation, his career, his childhood, his courtship with his wife, and his life now.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

An eye-opening look at the life of an independent man who must now rely on others for his most basic needs. Reeve's refusal to give into self pity is inspiring. His physical efforts to learn to breathe without a respirator and to regularly exercise his limbs are remarkable. To people around the world, Reeve is Superman and he has used this unique position to advocate for spinal injury research. We were touched by Reeve's portrayal of his wife and his obvious love of his children. We questioned how Reeve's life would differ from the average spinal cord injury victim. Would it be easier to keep hope alive if you looked out at the view Reeve enjoys on his book jacket?

 

January 2002

No Great Mischief by Alistair MacLeod

Synopsis:

A carefully constructed novel about family loyalty and Gaelic heritage. The rough, impoverished life of Calum MacDonald, orphan, miner, ex-convict is recollected by his younger brother, now a successful orthodontist living in Southern Ontario.

Their family is of the clan "Calum Ruadh" - descended from the strong-willed man who left the Scottish Highlands to settle in Cape Breton in 1779. The family motto is "blood is thicker than water" and members of the clan are recognized by others all over Canada (and in Scotland) by their black eyes and red hair. MacLeod, who was raised in Cape Breton, paints a meticulous yet moving picture of life on the east coast.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:


This novel was enjoyed by everyone. The narrative was simple, but many of the scenes stay with the reader.... the horse Christy pulling the boat to shore, Grandpa's frostbitten private parts, the impromptu fiddling concert at the mine, and the drive across the flooded causeway. We appreciated the MacDonald clan's love of their animals, their sense of humour and their loyalty.

November 2001

Spindle's End by Robin McKinley

Synopsis:


Everyone is familiar with the fairy tale Sleeping Beauty. In this novel, Robin McKinley adapts and expands the beloved story. McKinley's fairy tale country is thick with magic, which must be dusted from the doorsteps and emptied from the kettles.

On her christening day, Princess Briar Rose is snatched from the clutches of the wicked enchantress Pernicia by a young apprentice fairy. Rosie is then raised in obscurity in a remote farming village. She grows up without learning of her royal heritage and instead becomes a horse doctor and falls in love with the local blacksmith. When Rosie eventually confronts the spindle's end she proves to be a resourceful and powerful opponent of the evil Pernicia.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:


On the whole, this book was not well liked. Most found the plot simplistic and the characters one-dimensional. McKinley's writing is also very unstructured, using liberal quantities of parentheses and asides to the reader. We enjoyed the unique world of magic created by the novel and the involvement of the animals throughout the plot. It was also refreshing to read a fairy tale about a brave, quick-witted heroine who doesn't sit around waiting for her prince to come to the rescue.

October 2001

A Tree Grows In Brooklyn by Betty Smith

Synopsis:

Francie Nolan grows up in the school of hard-knocks in Brooklyn, New York at the turn of the century. Life with her charming but shiftless father, her lovely but severe mother, and her younger brother is tough and full of sacrifices. But Francie takes pleasure in small comforts; the chance to sleep in the front room; a visit from her Aunt Sissy; or the ability to use her "pinching penny" to buy a bag of broken sweets.

The author, Betty Smith was born on December 15, 1896, five years earlier than her fictional heroine. Smith also grew up poor in the Williamsburg section of Brooklyn, the world she re-creates with such meticulous detail in A Tree Grows in Brooklyn. This was her first novel.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:


Practically everyone enjoyed the story and found the Francie's experiences heartwarming and poignant. This book was very similar to Angela's Ashes, although the family was not as completely wretched. We experienced some confusion between the time in which the book was written and the time in which the story was set -many of us thought we were reading a story about the 1940s and had to remind ourselves that it was World War I not II. We felt great antipathy toward Francie's mother, especially when she forced Francie to leave school and support her brother's education.

The pictures conjured by the book will stay with you for a long time -especially the vision of the small girl sitting on the fire escape among the branches of the sumac tree with her bowl of peppermint candy and her library book.

September 2001

Cold Mountain by Charles Frazier

Synopsis:

Inman, a wounded Confederate soldier, leaves the hospital before he can be sent back to the front lines and begins the long journey to his sweetheart in the hills of North Carolina. Along the way, he meets both outlaws and kindly strangers and each of them become part of his story. As Inman travels through the mountains he draws strength from the natural beauty that surrounds him, even as he hides from those who would send him back to the war.

His sweetheart, meanwhile, has problems of her own. Raised as a Charleston society belle, Ada knows nothing about operating the farm. With the men off to war, she must learn to be self-sufficient. After a rocky beginning, and with the help of a drifter named Ruby, she eventually learns to wring a living from the land. Cold Mountain is the story of two parallel journeys: Inman's physical trek across the Blue Ridge Mountains and Ada's voyage of self discovery.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:


The Armchair Critics had a range of opinions about this book. The violent descriptions of the war were upsetting to some readers, however most felt that the story was a wonderful one. We noted its similarity to the Odyssey, with its long journey involving a series of encounters along the way. We especially enjoyed Ruby's blunt mannerisms and capable ways. Most of Armchair Critics identified more with Ada's story. We were somewhat disappointed with the ending. A lot of hard slogging with little pay-off!

Cold Mountain contains a quote from the poetry of Han-Shan a Buddhist poet and philosopher. Connie read from a copy of Han-Shan's book, (also called "Cold Mountain"), and we discussed the similar themes of the quest for enlightenment, and the simple enjoyment of living in the midst of Nature.

We enjoyed the lovely descriptions of places and events. Much research has obviously gone into the crafting of the book -from the methods of cooking and hunting to the period vocabulary used by Frazier (who must own a 1700's thesaurus!).

June 2001

High Fidelity by Nick Hornby

Synopsis:

Rob Zimmerman is the 30-something owner of a used record shop in London. Rob is a music snob with the amusing habits of creating endless "top five" hit lists and re-arranging his record collection during times of crisis.

Since he has just broken up with his longstanding girlfriend Laura, Rob decides to contact his previous top five girlfriends in an attempt to discover what's wrong with his love life. As he visits his old flames Rob evaluates his relationships with women and starts the long journey toward maturity. Hornby also introduces some excellent secondary characters, including the equally obsessive record store employees Dick and Barry.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

This book was discussed at our annual barbecue. There were many comparisons made between Rob and Helen Fielding's Bridget Jones. Both of these characters showed the same lack of self-confidence and basic life skills coupled with a high degree of success with the opposite sex. We also had a good discussion about the importance of music, good compilation tapes and our own top five lists of songs.

Interestingly, many of the Armchair Critics found Rob's behaviour childish, negative and annoying to the point of disliking the book, while most of the male guests at our barbecue found Rob amusing and thought he deserved points for showing his vulnerability. The women were also baffled by the fact that a successful lawyer like Laura would be willing to give this loser a second chance. Chalk that one up to Nick Hornby's male fantasies......although if Rob was really John Cusack......hmmmm.

 

May 2001

A Live Coal in the Sea - by Madeleine L'Engle

Synopsis:

The heroines of this book are Camilla Xanthakos, an astronomy professor at a small New England university and her granddaughter Raffi, a student at the same school. One evening Raffi comes to Camilla's house and asks, "are you my grandmother or not?" Camilla then delves into four generations of family history involving desertion, infidelity, miscarriage, untimely death, and a four-year-old torn from his parents. It is not until the final few pages of the book that Raffi's true parentage is revealed.

L'Engle weaves the theme of mercy throughout the novel. Even when her life is at its most turbulent, Camilla demonstrates the strength of forgiveness and the healing nature of love. L'Engle compares the effect of God's mercy on a troubled soul to a live coal dropped in the sea.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

We enjoyed the book although some of us found Camilla a little too good to be true. Her ability to teach university courses while raising two infants was certainly quite unusual! The group had an interesting discussion about mercy. What makes an act merciful and not simply self-serving? How can we teach our children to be merciful in an increasingly self-absorbed society? We watched a short biographical video about Madeleine L'Engle and concluded that she had modelled Camilla on herself. She used some of the same philosophical speeches, discussed galaxies and higher math and demonstrated the art of listening to trees! A very interesting lady. One member was heard to observe "I want to be like her when I grow up!"

 

April 2001

For Love - by Sue Miller

Synopsis:

It's summer and Lottie Gardner has returned to her childhood home. She and her teenage son are sorting through her mother's possessions and readying the house for sale. Lottie is retreating from a difficult marriage to a widower who is still grieving for his first wife. As she strips wallpaper and sorts through old clothes, Lottie tries to make sense of her relationships with her son and her new husband. Meanwhile, Lottie's childhood rival, Elizabeth, also returns to the neighbourhood and begins a steamy affair with Lottie's brother Cam.

Events take a nasty turn when Cam is involved in a car accident that kills Elizabeth's au pair on the same evening that Elizabeth's husband comes home. As Lottie deals with the emotional fallout from Elizabeth, her brother ,and her son she comes to a better understanding of the nature of love.

 

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

Miller does an excellent job of revealing her characters "warts and all". We found we had a tendency to judge Lottie harshly because she was not portrayed as the noble heroine. Members with teenage children thought that the relationship between Lottie and her son Ryan especially well done. The little details of this book were what made the characters live - Lottie's past bout with breast cancer, her ex-husband's new wife and baby, the gourmet sandwiches she buys as a treat for Ryan. Although we enjoyed the book, members who had read others by Sue Miller felt that this was not one of her best -not because of the writing, but because of the characters were so difficult to love.

 

March 2001

A Good House -by Bonnie Bernard

Synopsis:

The ordinary life of the Chambers family is rendered in extraordinary detail in Bonnie Bernards first full-length novel. Although the book spans fifty years, it touches down at odd intervals - each chapter taking the reader one, five, or seven years into the family's future. New babies are born, divorce takes place and romance blooms.

Sometimes the story dwells on ordinary moments, other times it reveals how swiftly lives are shot down by tragedy. However, the bonds of family are a constant source of love and strength for its members. The good house is real - we've all felt the rough paint of its porch beneath our fingers as we draw comfort from familiar surroundings and hear the laughter of our loved ones from within.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

We felt this was a lovely book. We breezed through the beginning of each chapter wondering what had happened to the family while we turned the page. The descriptions of everyday surroundings - the beach house, the creek, the house itself were beautifully made. We enjoyed the local setting and recognizing the streetscapes of London and the shores of Lake Huron.

Some of us found the explosion of grandchildren difficult to follow in the later chapters of the book, but enjoyed the exploration of the devastating effects of dementia on the patient and his loved ones. We found Margaret wise and wonderful, though perhaps a little too saintly and wondered if we would be equal to the challenge of raising someone else's family so smoothly. We enjoyed seeing the little town come of age over the fifty years, as if it too was a character in the novel. Highly recommended.

 

February 2001

Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone -by J.K. Rowling

Synopsis:

Harry is a young orphan who is living with his nasty relatives when he's summoned to claim his magical heritage by attending Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. Instead of math and literature, he studies potions and care of magical creatures and learns how to ride a broomstick and use a magic wand. It's an enchanting world where the mail is delivered by owls, ghosts roam the hallways and the paintings on the wall visit one another.

It also turns out that Harry's parents were killed by an evil wizard so powerful that everyone is afraid to even say his name, Voldemort. With the help of his new friends Ron and Hermione, Harry solves a mystery involving an enchanted stone that ultimately takes him to the evil Voldemort.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

We thought this was a delightful book. It has the perfect mixture of fun, action and mystery which keeps the interest of both children and adults. We enjoyed all the details of the wizard world and their inability to comprehend the muggle way of life. Rowling is an excellent writer and many of us plan to check out the rest of the series.

January 2001

Notes From a Big Country - Bill Bryson

Synopsis:

Bill Bryson was born in Iowa, but moved to Britain in 1973. He lived in the United Kingdom for over twenty years before returning to the United States with his English wife and family in tow. Notes from a Big Country is a collection of essays about his impressions of life in America.

The book contains the best material from several years worth of his weekly column in a British magazine. Some of his themes are; Americans don't walk enough, the American war against drugs, junk food as a blight on society, and the abundance of wild open space. His conversational writing style is enjoyable and perfect for this type of material.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

Everyone loved this book. We all had our favorite stories and pithy phrases. There was an interesting discussion about Bryson's belief that American's have no sense of irony. We thought that perhaps some aspects of our sense of humour and way of life in Canada is closer to Britain than to the United States. The Critics felt that the book is perfect to pick up when you only have time to read a few pages since the columns are short and you put it down with a smile on your face.

November 2000

Daisy Bates in the Desert - Julia Blackburn

Synopsis:

Daisy Bates lived and worked amongst the Australian Aboriginal people from 1919 to 1945. During this time she studied their customs, languages and legends. She was given the name of Kabbarli (grandmother) by the Aboriginals and eventually awarded the Order of the British Empire. During her time in the desert, Mrs. Bates lived in a tent on the edge of the Nullarbor Plain, notably at a place called Ooldea in South Australia. She helped feed, clothe and nurse the transient population, using her own money to meet their pressing needs. She died in relative obscurity in 1951.

Julia Blackburn has written a book that is in part a biography and in part an imaginary re-creation of the isolated life of Daisy Bates. Blackburn's attempt to uncover the facts about Bates is interspersed with suppositions and her personal insights and dreams.

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

Blackburn's unusual biographical technique was not well liked by the group. There was much confusion over which aspects of Daisy Bates life were real and which were invented. The group was also disappointed by the lack of detail about Aboriginal life and Bates' real relationship with the people she worked with. While her paternalistic attitude was off-putting, Bates was applauded for being genuinely concerned with the welfare of the Aboriginals and for not attempting to convert them to western ways. It was an interesting story that could have been so much more enlightening.

 

October 2000

"O" the Oprah Magazine

Synopsis:

According to Oprah's web site, "O" is the women's personal-growth guide for the new century. It gives confident, smart women the tools they need to explore and reach for their dreams, to express their individual style, and to make choices that will lead to a happier and more fulfilling life. With one of the most trusted women in America inspiring the editorial content, this magazine serves as a catalyst for transforming women's lives.

 

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

There was a lively discussion about "O". We watched a videotape of Oprah on the Rosie O'Donnell Show talking about the launch of the magazine. It was interesting to hear about her hopes for the magazine. Oprah says that she wants to give the people who watch her show a chance to reflect on the issues and come back to them. We found her magazine to be an easily digestible version of a self-help book.

Several of our members said that they were not impressed by the many, many pages of ads and by the preachy tone of this magazine. However, those of us who buy more women's magazines, said that we found lots to read in "O" and that we would certainly get it again. We noted that the models in the fashion articles were the regular skinny types you see in all the magazines. Why doesn't Oprah use some plus-sized models? We also noted that although Oprah seems to want to reach out to the common woman, her magazine was featuring some very pricey items (like the $1,500 boots in one fashion spread).

September 2000

Into Thin Air - Jon Krakauer

Synopsis:

A personal account of the 1996 Mount Everest disaster. Krakauer recounts the physical and mental cost of such a climb. Even under the best of circumstances, each step up the ice-clad mountain is monumentally exhausting, and the oxygen-deprived brain loses the ability to make reliable judgements. And on May 10, 1996, when Hall's expedition and several others made their summit assault, the conditions were far from ideal. The mountain was so "crowded" that climbers had to wait their turn near the summit while their bottled oxygen dwindled by the minute. By afternoon a blinding hurricane-force storm had stranded a number of climbers on the highest, most exposed reaches of the mountain. By the end of the day, twelve lives were lost.

 

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

This was our Book Club Barbecue choice. Most of us found it a difficult book to read. Although compellingly written and full of stunning detail, the book was also full of stunningly selfish people. We concluded that mountain climbers must have no thought for the emotional and financial turmoil they put their families through. What a waste of money and effort!

June 2000

Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil - John Berendt

Synopsis:

A true story of the eccentric characters and steamy mansions of Savannah Georgia built around the murder trial of Jim Williams, a wealthy southern gentleman. Berendt travels to Savannah to write a book and makes the acquaintance of many colourful locals. He is invited to some of the City's exclusive social events including the Married Womens' Bridge Club and the Black Debutantes' Ball.

The imprisonment and trial of Williams form the narrative thread that stitches together this collection of voodoo priestesses, drag queens and quick tempered hustlers. A remarkable book that proves the expression "the truth is stranger than fiction"!

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

We thought this book was extremely well-written and we were quickly drawn into the lives, gossip and dramas of the inhabitants. We enjoyed the way Savannah society was completely isolated from the rest of the United States. One of our members compared the insular society of Savannah with the small villages of Agatha Christie novels. We were fascinated by the characters -especially the Lady Chablis, and the lovable scoundrel Joe Odin. Some of us also watched the film, but most felt that the book was far superior.

May 2000

The Sweet Hereafter - Russell Banks

Synopsis:

Following a tragic school bus accident, the people of a small town try to come to terms with the deaths of their children. The characters include: the school bus driver, the father of twins killed in the crash, a New York lawyer out for revenge, and a fourteen year old girl crippled by the accident. The reader experiences the story from inside the heads of these four characters in turn--each knowing things the others don't, each misunderstanding the facts in his or her own way. The characters are further revealed through the observations of others in the novel.

 

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

The book was wonderfully crafted. We found its concentration on the aftermath of the tragedy rather than on the accident itself to be fascinating. The characters, while well-drawn, were not likable and seemed at times to represent stereotypes rather than people. The bleak atmosphere of the story is difficult to immerse yourself in, yet you are drawn to its conclusion in a fruitless search for a glimpse of happiness. We found the lawyer the most interesting character and liked the inclusion of his relationship with his daughter who is as lost to him as the town's children.

April 2000

The Pilot's Wife - Anita Shreve

Synopsis:

After her pilot husband's plane blows up off the coast of Ireland, Kathryn discovers bit by bit how little she knew Jack Lyons. First, she faces a media frenzy when the flight recorder makes clear that Jack was carrying a bomb in his flight bag. Her illusions of a her so-called good marriage crumble, despite her belief in the love she and Jack had and the need to keep Jack's memory pure for teenage daughter Mattie. As she navigates the dark days following her husband's death, Kathryn increasingly feels compelled to come to grips with Jack's hidden life.

 

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

While we found this book to be a real page-turner, none of us really felt that the story of Kathryn and her sorry marriage rang true. The confrontation with the other woman seemed too pat. We especially disliked the fact that Kathryn turns to the Union representative Richard at the story's conclusion even after he has also betrayed her. We wondered where her other friends were?

We thought that the descriptions of Kathryn's initial grief and shock were well-written and believable. We felt that we would rather be the woman betrayed than the woman taking part in the lie. The Armchair Critics felt that this would be an excellent film.

March 2000

Cyrano de Bergerac - Edmond Rostand

Synopsis:

This is the classic story of the dashing soldier with the large nose and larger-than-life personality. Cyrano loves the witty and beautiful Roxanne but is too ashamed of his physical appearance to woo her. He enlists the help of the handsome but tongue-tied Christian who is also madly in love with Roxanne.

Cyrano writes passionate and inspired poems and letters to Roxanne and Christian delivers them. When Christian is later mortally wounded in battle, Cyrano becomes Roxanne's lifelong friend and comforter.

 

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

We loved this romantic and poetic play -although some of us had difficulty finding an English version! Ronstand's verses are wonderful and we wished we had someone to compare the translation to the original French play. We thought that the depiction of steadfast and devoted love must be the main reason for the timeless appeal of Cyrano.

It was nice to see an intelligent and witty heroine in a story from this time period. We were intrigued to learn that Cyano was a real person and that he wrote some of the first science fiction books back in the 1600's. We also discussed the film versions of the play (Steve Martin's "Roxanne" and Gerard Depardieu's "Cyrano").

February 2000

Red China Blues - Jan Wong

Synopsis:

Jan Wong is a Canadian reporter of Chinese descent. "Red China Blues: My Long March from Mao to Now" is a detailed memoir of her years in China and her love-hate relationship with the country.

The book includes: Wong's six year stay in China during the Cultural Revolution; her initial Communist idealism which turned to disillusionment as she became aware of harsh reality; a moving account of the Tiananmen Square uprising; and her later years as a Globe and Mail correspondent during the capitalist reform.

 

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

We found this a fascinating glimpse into a country that few westerners experience. No detail is left out -from toilets to penis extensions -we get the whole story. Wong's style is familiar and chatty, although some members found her personality overwhelming at times. We concluded that the book would have been more enjoyable if Wong had been less self-absorbed.

January 2000

Cry to Heaven - Anne Rice

Synopsis:

Two men in love with music are at the centre of this novel. Tonio is a youth from a noble Venetian family who sneaks out at night to sing in the streets. His future marriage and happiness is destroyed when a jealous rival has him kidnapped and castrated. Guido is a peasant sold into the world of song at six who rises to the top of the class and performs at the opera in Rome. At age 18 he tragically loses his voice. Tormented by this loss, Guido plunges himself into composition and searches for another wonderful voice. He eventually finds Tonio and becomes his teacher.

 

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

This was an enjoyable novel. Anne Rice's descriptions of 18th Century Italy are vivid and enthralling. The history of the castrati and their superstar status was a fascinating topic and Rice has obviously done her research. Some members thought the emphasis on Tonio's sex life became a little repetitive, but we all enjoyed the story.

 

November 1999

Angela's Ashes -Frank McCourt

Synopsis:

"Angela's Ashes" is the melancholy story of an impoverished Irish Catholic family as told through the eyes of their eldest son: Frank McCourt. The strength of the book lies in the vivid characterizations, the honesty of the narrative and the beautifully descriptive writing. The McCourt family is reduced to begging, to painting their legs black in order to hide the holes in their stockings and to living in a house with an outhouse used by the entire neighbourhood. "Angela's Ashes" is a story of survival against great odds. McCourt neatly captures the feeling of what it was like to grow up in abject poverty, suffering tremendous hunger and humiliation on a daily basis.

 

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

Our members really enjoyed the book, although most of us found the first third very difficult to read due to the deaths of the three little ones. We were impressed by Mr. McCourt's simple writing style, and by his inclusion of incidents which must have been embarrassing and painful to re-live. We were disappointed by Angela's lack of action to save her family from hunger, but concluded that we were wishing for a Hollywood ending that could not have occurred in reality. We look forward to reading McCourt's sequel to "Angela's Ashes" entitled " 'Tis".

October 1999

How Reading Changed my Life -Anna Quindlen

Synopsis:

Anna Quindlen's tribute to reading will help you recall your early printed friends and how you felt when an unread title by a favorite author appeared at the library. Quindlen boldly declares that she has been a voracious reader all her life, not because she wants to educate or better herself, but because she just loves reading "more than any other activity on earth." She believes that many people feel this way because books both "lessen isolation" and help readers escape the demands of everyday life. Reading, she says, is an "undersung" source of pleasure and comfort that ranks right up there with "God, sex, food, family, friends."

 

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

This book held plenty of food for thought. We liked that fact that Quindlen does not discriminate between literature and mass market pulp fiction -stating that all reading fulfils an important purpose. We enjoyed reminiscing about our own childhood favourites and wondered how to teach our children to love books as we do. We agreed that books on disk will not replace books on paper any time soon!

September 1999

Bridget Jones' Diary -Helen Fielding

Synopsis:

In the course of the year recorded in Bridget Jones's Diary, Bridget confides her hopes,her dreams, and her fluctuating weight, not to mention her consumption of 5277 cigarettes. In 365 days, she gains 74 pounds. On the other hand, she loses 72! There is also the unspoken New Year's resolution--the quest for the right man. Alas, here Bridget goes severely off course when she has an affair with her charming cad of a boss. Fielding reveals the lighter side of despair, self-doubt, and obsession, and also satirises everything from self-help books (they don't sound half as sensible to Bridget when she's sober) to feng shui, Cosmopolitan-style.

 

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

Our members had strong opinions about this book. They either found it screamingly funny, or they found it silly and senseless! Those who found it funny enjoyed the satire of everyday single life and the ironic situations Bridget finds herself in. The parallels with "Pride and Prejudice" were also amusing. Those who found the "Diary" annoying thought that Jones was unbelievably inept and self-delusional! We concluded that you have to be in the mood for something light and airy in order to appreciate the humour in this book.

August 1999

Midwives -Chris Bohajalian

Synopsis:

This novel chronicles the events leading up to the trial of Sibyl Danforth, a respected midwife in a small Vermont town, on charges of manslaughter. The prosecuting attorney and the medical community are all anxious to use this tragedy as ammunition against midwifery in general. Through it all, Sibyl, her husband, and their teenage daughter, Connie, attempt to keep their family intact, but the stress of the trial--and Sibyl's growing closeness to her lawyer--puts pressure on the marriage.

 

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

This book was a pleasant page-turner which kept you guessing about Sibyl's guilt until the conclusion. Most enjoyed the book, although they felt that Sibyl's character was unsympathetic because she valued the 'high' she got from delivering babies over anything her family had to offer. An interesting discussion about midwifery vs. the established medical community.

July 1999

Lives of the Saints -Nino Ricci

Synopsis:

Vittorio Innocente's childhood is shattered when his mother, Christina, has an affair with a blue-eyed stranger. His tiny Italian village harbours century-old superstitions, and fears. The villagers' self-righteousness harms Vittorio and his mother. But as he pieces together the story of his mother's 'crime', Vittorio discovers the truth about the villagers and gains a new understanding of human nature.

 

 

What the Armchair Critics Thought:

The majority of our members did not enjoy this book. Some disliked the portrayal of Italians as superstitious and backward. We found the perspective of the little boy irritating because the reader was left guessing about what was really going on. We found the book trailed off and left many loose ends (though we note that there are two sequels that probably tie them up). Connie read a very amusing article by the author (who lives in Toronto, Ontario) about his relationship with the local Italian community.

Other Books We've Discussed

This is an additional list of most of the books we have read since our first meeting on September 19, 1987.

 The Beet Queen
Songs of Distant Earth
Wilt on High
Love in a Cold Climate
The Marriage Bed
The Handmaid's Tale by Margaret Atwood
Tiger in a Tiger Pit
Whirlwind
Sex and Destiny
The Summertree
The Dieter
Much Depends on Dinner by Margaret Visser
 Diet for a Small Planet
The Accidental Tourist by Anne Tyler
Lonesome Dove
Gorillas in the Mist
Downfall People
The Joy Luck Club by Amy Tan
The Wars by Timothy Findley
100 Years of Solitude
Straight from the Heart
My Mother, Myself
Her Mother's Daughter
Ender's Game by Orson Scott Card
Speaker for the Dead by Orson Scott Card
You'll See it When You Believe It
Ladies of Missalonghi
Witches of Eastwick
The Blue Castle by L.M. Montgomery
Something Wicked This Way Comes
The Dancing Chicken
The Cider House Rules
A Matter of Honour
 Prince of Tides by Pat Conroy
Jean's Way by Derek Humphrey
Dance of Anger by Harriet Goldhor Lerner
Jurassic Park by Michael Creighton
Living, Loving and Learning by Leo Buscaglia
The Firm by John Grisham
A Circle of Friends by Maeve Binchy
We the Living by Ann Ryand
Fried Green Tomatoes by Fannie Flagg
The Tent Peg by Aretha Van Herk
The Kitchen God's Wife by Amy Tan
Alive by Piers Paul Read
Obisan by Joy Kogawa
Diana, Her True Story by Andrew Morton
The Little Country by Charles deLint
A Year in Provence by Peter Mayle
Eye of the Dragon by Steven King
Oh Canada! Oh Quebec! by Mordecai Richler
The Outport People by Claire Mowat
Desire by Amanda Quick
The English Patient by Michael Ondaatje
Die for Love by Elizabeth Peters
 The Snapper by Roddy Doyle
The Rising Sun by Michael Crighton
Shadowlands
Passage to India by E.M. Forster
On the Beach by Nevil Shute
Roughing it in the Bush by Suzanna Moodie
Interview with a Vampire by Ann Rice
The Stone Diaries by Carol Sheilds
The Celestine Prophecy by James Redfield
Dance on the Earth by Margaret Lawrence
A City Called July by Howard Engel
Virus Outbreak by Robin Cook
The Survival of Jan Little
Smilla's Sense of Snow by Peter Hoyle
Murther and Other Walking Spirits by Robertson Davis
 Shylock's Daughter by Erica Jong
Brother Haluin's Confession by Ellis Peters
84 Charing Cross Road by Helene Hanff
Sense and Sensibility by Jane Austen
The Bridges of Maddison County by Robert James Waller
 Five Days in Paris by Danielle Steele
The Piano Man's Daughter by Timothy Findley
Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus by Robert Gray
Snow Falling on Cedars by David Guterson
Traitor's Gate by Ann Perry
Neuromancer by William Gibson
The Christmas Box by Richard Paul Evans
The Eagle and the Rose by Rosemay Altea
Talk Before Sleep by Elizabeth Berg
Thirteen Hands by Carol Sheilds
Born in Fire by Nora Roberts
Uncle Tom's Cabin by Harriet Beacher Stowe
The Pig and the Python by David Cork
The Shell Seekers by Rosamund Pilcher
How the Irish Saved Civilization by Thomis Cahill
Why Bad Things Happen to Good People
The Terminal Experiment by Robert Sawyer
Undue Influence by Steve Martini
Ishmael by Daniel Quinn
Animal Dreams by Barbara Kingsolver
The Englishman's Boy by Guy Vanderhaeghe
Happenstance by Carol Shields
 The Snow Leopard by Peter Matheson
Stones from the River by Ursula Hegi
Beachcombing for a Shipwrecked God by Joe Coombes
The Scarlet Pimpernell by Baroness D'Orczy